“We appointed Fletcher Jones with a broad brief. We wanted to add diversity in terms of what the candidate would add to the board. This might originate from gender, ethnicity, nationality or simply different experience. We also wanted someone who could contribute a macro perspective to a fund which is managed very much bottom-up.
We discussed the brief with Fletcher Jones and it was clear that they had got it.
Subsequently, we agreed a long list of nine, which they interviewed. Due to the quality of this diverse list, we had considerable difficulty reducing it to four, who we interviewed. The challenge continued in reducing that number to the successful candidate. I have been involved in searches where I was enthused by one candidate alone. In this case, we would have been happy to appoint any of the last four, and probably most of the last nine. It was an outstanding performance by Fletcher Jones.”
Robbie Robertson, Chair, Lowland Investment Company
“None of our Board had worked with Fletcher Jones prior to engaging them to find a new NED with smaller company fund management experience. We were open minded as to whether or not the candidates had NED experience as we were keen to find someone able to challenge our managers constructively as well as add to the diversity of views around our Board table. We were impressed with the long list Fletcher Jones presented for our consideration within a relatively short timeframe, the care taken with FJ interviews of the short list we decided on and the professional management of the entire process. We had worried that having to undertake the whole process remotely would create difficulties but I think I can speak for the Board in saying that our misgivings were misplaced. We are looking forward to working with our new Board colleague and would happily consider using Fletcher Jones again.”
Jane Lewis, Chair, Invesco Perpetual UK Smaller Companies Trust
"We engaged Fletcher Jones to help find an experienced NED to join our Board. We hadn't worked with them before but, as anticipated, they added value from the outset as we worked together to develop our initial role profile. This reflected our willingness to consider candidates from a wide range of different backgrounds, each of which would complement the experience of existing Board members. So we didn't make life easy for them, but they responded brilliantly by producing a very strong list of prospects with an impressive and diverse range of skills. They produced helpful candidate profiles, arranged the now familiar 'Zoom interviews' and generally coordinated the entire process effectively and efficiently. The demanding timetable agreed at the outset was met and the BCPT Board are delighted with the appointment that has now been made. We enjoyed working with Fletcher Jones and would be happy to do so again in the future.”
Martin Moore, Chair, BMO Commercial Property Trust
"We gave Fletcher Jones a challenging brief to find a new NED with wealth management and investment experience and a broader knowledge of the wider industry and current issues affecting investment companies. We were happy to consider candidates who had no previous NED experience and encouraged Fletcher Jones to produce a diverse long list. We also stressed that we were keen to ensure that our appointee would add to, and not just duplicate, the skills of existing Board members. Fletcher Jones quickly understood what we were looking for, and their detailed feedback from the nine interviews they conducted with candidates selected by us from their long list was particularly helpful in enabling us to consider skill set, personality and fit and to refine our thoughts. In the end, we interviewed a shortlist of 3 candidates. We are delighted with the outcome and are now very much looking forward to welcoming the successful candidate on board. We are very grateful to Fletcher Jones for their efficient and careful handling of the whole process and would be happy to consider using them again."
Wendy Colquhoun, Chair, Henderson Opportunities Trust
"We tasked Fletcher Jones with a brief for a current affairs expert with European focus. This is by no means a standard brief in investment trusts, but they approached it with imagination, checking back at several stages to see if they were on the right track. They researched academia, journalism, public service and think tanks and the result was a first-class list of candidates from whom we were able to select our new director. The process kept perfectly to the initially indicated timescale and was efficient and diligent."
Vivian Bazalgette, Chair, Fidelity European Trust
"Following a tender process we chose Fletcher Jones to search for a senior fixed income specialist. We weren't disappointed. Although we had provided a detailed brief, they took the trouble to arrange a personal meeting before we awarded the contract, and the interaction afterwards was faultless. The process was professional and ran smoothly, the long list was impressively diverse and from an excellent gender-balanced shortlist we were able to recruit a first-class candidate. I can't praise FJ too highly."
John Boothman, NomCom Chair, City Merchants High Yield Trust Ltd
"To recruit a new CEO, we first sought to identify the right agency to conduct the search. Fletcher Jones came top in a competitive process due to their clearly communicated approach, understanding of our needs and what a 'good fit' for us may look like. They produced a strong candidate list, supported by objectively written reports. At each stage Fletcher Jones gave timely, clear, and appropriate updates which smoothed the selection process along to final interview and a successful, high-quality appointment. A debrief by the Board concluded that we were very pleased with the service Fletcher Jones provided and have no hesitation in recommending them. I personally felt that the team worked hard to help us find not just a great CEO but the right CEO for Metfriendly, the Board and our members."
Joanna Young, Chair, Metfriendly
“As part of our Board succession strategy, there was a need to replace an experienced and long-serving NED who was approaching the end of their permitted term of service. Following an analysis of Board skills, we engaged Fletcher Jones to support us with this assignment. The brief was to identify a NED with the potential to take on the role of SID, or Chairman, in the coming years and who had a Marketing, Distribution and Finance background., Fletcher Jones were able to bring their knowledge and expertise to the table and compile a strong list of candidates with the appropriate qualities we were looking for. The assignment was extremely well conducted from start to finish and resulted in a successful appointment to the Board. We would certainly use Fletcher Jones again and would not hesitate in recommending them.”
William Schouten, Chair of the Nomination & Remuneration Committee, Cirencester Friendly Society Limited
“A recent review of our succession strategy identified a need for the replacement of two of the Society’s longest-serving NEDs. Following an analysis of Board skills, we again turned to Fletcher Jones to support us with the two assignments. Our brief was to identify NEDs with Marketing and Finance backgrounds. In both cases, Fletcher Jones was able to source a strong list of candidates with the appropriate qualities we were looking for. Both of the assignments resulted in successful appointments to the Board. We would certainly use Fletcher Jones again and would not hesitate in recommending them.”
Andrew Horsley, Vice-Chair and Chair of the Nomination & Remuneration Committee, Chorley Building Society
“We approached Fletcher Jones to work on a NED assignment. This was our first experience of using them and we have been very impressed. From the initial briefing through to short listing and interview the Fletcher Jones team have been professional, approachable, and always very efficient. We had confidence in their approach from the updates and clear communication with us at each stage of the process. That confidence was further embedded with the provision of a strong candidate list that led to a great appointment for us. A positive experience all round.”
Kimberly Johnstone, Director of People and Corporate Services, The Medical and Dental Defence Union of Scotland
“We have worked with Fletcher Jones on a brief to appoint a NED to our board. This is the second assignment we have given them, and once again their service was excellent. They are creative, attentive and efficient. We tasked them with seeking out a range of candidates with diverse backgrounds and we were extremely impressed by the quality and breadth of people that Fletcher Jones put forward. I would have no hesitation in recommending them.”
Simon Whale, Chair, PG Mutual
“I have been extremely impressed with Fletcher Jones throughout the process of recruiting a Non-Executive Director for The Exeter and would have no hesitation in using their services again and recommending them to others.”
Andy Chapman, Chief Executive, The Exeter
“Scottish Equity Partners have worked with Fletcher Jones for over 10 years assisting with appointments to our own team as well as investee company director appointments. They are excellent to work with, develop a thorough understanding of the brief, have extensive coverage of the candidate population and provide a strong and competitive shortlist of candidates.
We retained Fletcher Jones on a search to strengthen our infrastructure investment team in London. As always we were impressed with their grasp of the brief, coverage and professional pride evidenced in their team’s approach to the assignment and were delighted with the outcome.”
Gary Le Sueur, Partner, Scottish Equity Partners
“First Sentier Investors has a longstanding history of appointing independent directors, retaining its first non-executive director in 2011 with the support of Fletcher Jones. By bringing in a diverse skill set across our non-executive population, we aim to ensure the firm remains aligned with best-practice corporate governance while deepening our boards’ existing skills and expertise. Fletcher Jones has been instrumental in helping us achieve this objective, and over the years has assisted us through the appointment of a further two non-executive appointments that have each made a significant contribution to our board composition.”
Chris Turpin, Global Director of Corporate Development and Managing Director (EMEA), First Sentier Investors
The Investment Committee of West of England appointed Fletcher Jones to perform a search for two new independent directors. The management and the Board were looking for very high-profile investment professionals with an excellent understanding of the investment environment and challenges for general insurers. We were very pleased with the breadth and quality of candidates identified across Europe and the assistance to manage the selection process. Fletcher Jones did a very good job and I am very happy to recommend them to others.”
Thierry Brevet, General Manager and CIO, The West of England Ship Owners Mutual Insurance Association (Luxembourg)
"Sarasin's Nomination Committee considered a number of options to help find a suitable NED to join its LLP Board. We concluded that Fletcher Jones offered the more bespoke service, which was closely aligned with our needs. The search and evaluation process was rigorous, culminating in a high-quality shortlist from which we were able to appoint a seasoned professional who I'm sure, will add value to our decision making. I commend the team at Fletcher Jones for both a successful outcome and timely delivery of the project."
Gary Steinberg, Chair of Nominations Committee, Sarasin & Partners
“We appointed Fletcher Jones to assist with the search for a new partner in our corporate practice. The process worked very well. We were impressed by the work carried out by Fletcher Jones on shortlisting candidates and it really felt like a collaborative approach. We are very pleased with the successful appointment and would not hesitate to recommend the Fletcher Jones team for other appointments.”
Bruce Farquhar, Chair, Anderson Strathern
“We set a tight, challenging brief in terms of the attributes of the ideal candidate we were looking for to fill a key role in our firm. This meant the likely appointee would need to relocate from a big city to a regional centre. Fletcher Jones filled us with confidence with their hands-on approach and the impressive shortlist prepared for us, which demonstrated they understood exactly who we were looking for. The candidates were not only of the prerequisite calibre, but also a good fit with our culture. We are delighted with our new partner.”
David Smith, Managing Partner, Henderson Loggie
“Fletcher Jones were appointed to find a senior private client lawyer with a diverse set of skills who was established in the Edinburgh market. A priority for us on this search was to ensure that the fit was right for our established legal team and we needed someone to come in to succeed to the management of this team and take the team with them and for the change to be managed carefully. I am always reassured working with Fletcher Jones that they truly take on board and understand what is important to us and ensure this is the case before they bring candidates to us. In the latest appointment, Fletcher Jones have done this was handled to their usual high standard and most importantly they ensured that they continued to be fully involved and managed the process even after a candidate has tendered their resignation when there can still be risks to overcome.”
Carole Tomlinson, Partner and Head of Private Client
“Having been retained on searches for a number of senior appointments in recent years, Fletcher Jones has gained a good understanding of our firm’s culture and of how challenging it can be to recruit top calibre senior lawyers in a highly competitive market. When a much sought-after individual became available, Fletcher Jones responded quickly and supported our recruitment process despite a few counter offers and secured a valued addition to our corporate & commercial team. Fletcher Jones lived up to its ‘trusted advisor’ reputation.”
Murray McCall, Managing Partner Anderson Strathern
not for profit
“Fletcher Jones worked with the Edinburgh Academy to recruit a Commercial Director to head up our trading activity. The team at Fletcher Jones were a pleasure to work with due to their professionalism and their ability to steer us through this process to a very successful conclusion. Despite working to tight timelines, they took the time at the start of the process to develop a really good understanding of our business, our requirements and the team. This proved to be invaluable later in the recruitment process as they were able to offer insightful advice and guidance at critical times. I highly commend them to you and will be very happy use them again.”
Guy Cartwright, Bursar, Edinburgh Academy
“With over £1.1bn of assets to look after it is essential that we attract Trustees of the very highest calibre. The Fletcher Jones Team were a delight to work with. Well organised and completely professional, they provided an intelligent and diverse panel of candidates and gave us the support we needed to secure two outstanding new Trustees.”
Ian Blackford, Chair, Golden Charter Trust
"Fletcher Jones took time to understand both our cultural context and operational requirements and delivered an excellent range of candidates that exceeded expectations".
Matthew Carpenter, Head of Finance/Company Secretary, The Salvation Army
“Further to our recent inclusion into the FTSE 250 the Board of Baillie Gifford Shin Nippon decided for the first time to commission external assessments of the Independent Directors, the Board effectiveness as a unit and the Chair’s overall performance. After an extensive search, the Board decided to commission Fletcher Jones to conduct this piece of work on our behalf. I had the pleasure of scoping the work with the team at Fletcher Jones and I was delighted that the timelines the Board had in mind were workable. The whole research process was incredibly thorough on the one hand yet seemingly painless on the other! A large number of stakeholders were approached by Fletcher Jones to comment on the brief and their thoughts and insights were woven into the final report.
The Shin Nippon Board were impressed with the professionalism of the team at Fletcher Jones. The report is thorough and addresses all the issues agreed in the initial brief. The Board of Shin Nippon would have no hesitation in recommending Fletcher Jones for any similar exercise in mind.”
Neil Donaldson, Chair, Baillie Gifford Shin Nippon PLC
"As a Board, we commission an independent Directors’ Evaluation and Remuneration Review on a regular basis. Having just commenced our Board rotation process, we were particularly keen that the review was specifically tailored to our current circumstances in order to capture the views of those Directors about to step down from the Board as well as those from our more recent appointees. Fletcher Jones were professional, efficient and robust in their approach, interviewing all Directors as well as our Fund Manager and key advisers. The reports they have produced for us are comprehensive, helpful and constructive. We would be happy to use them on another occasion."
Alison Fyfe, Remuneration & Nomination Committee Chair, Target Healthcare REIT plc
“Having been through considerable change of both board composition and service providers in recent years, the Board was keen to have a thorough evaluation to support and improve our future functioning. After a competitive tender, Fletcher Jones was selected as their proposal was robust and the pricing attractive. We were not disappointed. Individual sessions were conducted with all directors and other key people (all during the Covid-19 pandemic period) and the resulting report was comprehensive, clear and helpful.
Caroline Hitch, Chair, CQS New City High Yield Fund Limited
"As we approached the 2-year anniversary of our IPO, our Board was keen to commission an independent board effectiveness and remuneration review. Following a competitive tender process, we selected Fletcher Jones as we believe they presented the best combination of experience, approach and value for money. All interviews were conducted very efficiently and virtually during the Covid-19 pandemic. The Board was delighted with the output and we asked Fletcher Jones to present at our most recent board meeting. We were very appreciative of their empathy, experience and recommendations, which were all delivered very effectively to our Board."
Mark Pacitti, Chair, Smithson Investment Trust plc